I love the month of April. The weather is getting warmer. The days are getting longer. Flowers are starting to bud. (The pollen is, too…but I choose to ignore that.) The garden is almost ready for planting. But most importantly, April means its time to get the grill out and ready for summer grilling! My wife and I use the grill at least 3-4 nights a week during the summer months. So you can imagine our excitement when grill season arrives! Nothing beats the taste of cooking over lump charcoal with a few chunks of hickory wood thrown in for flavor.
This year, I’ve decided to mix up my grilling routine. Not that there’s anything wrong with burgers and hotdogs on the grill, but I want to experiment a bit more. To help with this project, I decided to invite some friends over and host a grill-off. Since the grill was just coming out of winter hibernation, I figured some delicious steaks needed to be involved. So before the grill-off, I ran over to Walmart and picked up several USDA Choice Premium steaks. I grabbed several different cuts of steak (rib-eye and New York strip) just to mix it up a bit. The rules for the grill-off were pretty simple: create the tastiest dish possible using steak. So armed with delicious steaks and a clean grill, we were off. (As a side note, hosting a grill-off would be a fun activity for your Memorial Day picnic with friends and neighbors!)
To be fair, I have to confess that the competitors in my grill-off were allowed to marinate their steaks ahead of time. Dale decided to go with the classic steakhouse approach and serve a marinated steak alongside a loaded double-stuffed baked potato. Missy, on the other hand, decided to go a different route and turn her steak into a steak sandwich complete with peppers, onions, and provolone cheese. Not to take anything away from Dale’s and Missy’s creativity, but the quality of the meat made a huge difference here, too. As any good chef will tell you, the quality of the ingredients is the secret to making the best dishes. So next time you find yourself near Walmart, swing by the meat section and pick up some of their USDA Choice Premium Beef. (Only 1 in 5 steaks makes the cut to be called Walmart Choice Premium Beef.)
But back to the grill-off! My wife and I served as judges (it was a tough job!), and both dishes were incredibly tasty. Dale’s steak was a more traditional fork and knife style, while Missy’s was perfect for a casual backyard picnic. My wife and I sampled both dishes (ok, maybe devoured is more accurate), and we decided that the winner was….. Well, no surprise here. The grill-off ended in a 1-1 tie. (Mental note: next time have an odd number of judges.) Guess you’ll just have to make both recipes and decide on the winner yourself! Happy Spring from Spiced, and stay tuned for tons more grilling ideas and tips in the coming months!
Ingredients
- 2 3/4"-1" New York Strip or Ribeye steaks (approximately same size)
- 2 cloves garlic, coursely chopped
- 1/2 medium red onion, coursely chopped
- 2 tsp dried oregano
- 1/4 cup olive oil
- 1 Tbsp worcestershire sauce
- 2 tsp soy sauce
- 1 tsp kosher salt
- 1 tsp ground black pepper
- 2 3/4"-1" New York Strip or Ribeye steaks
- 2-3 bell peppers (use a mix of green and red), cut into strips
- 1 medium red onion, cut into strips
- 2 Tbsp + 1 Tbsp olive oil
- 2 hoagie-style sandwich buns
- salt, to taste
- pepper, to taste
- 2 deli-style slices provolone cheese
Instructions
- Combine all ingredients (other than the steaks) together and stir until well combined. Place steaks along with the marinade in a zip-loc bag. Seal bag and refrigerate for 4-6 hours.
- Remove bag from refrigerator ~30 minutes prior to grilling.
- Heat grill and get grate as hot as possible (ideally ~600 degrees).
- Place steaks on grill, close cover and grill for 2 minutes.
- Flip steaks and close cover. Grill for 2 more minutes.
- Turn off the grill completely and let the steaks roast in the warm grill for 3-6 minutes. (Note: You may have to adjust this roasting time based on thickness of your steaks and personal preference.)
- Remove steaks from grill and let rest for at least 5 minutes before serving.
- Place steaks in the freezer for about 45 minutes prior to cooking. (If you go much longer, then the steaks will be too hard to slice.)
- Combine sliced peppers, onions, and toss with 1 Tbsp olive oil. Place in a cast iron pan with salt and pepper and saute until they reach desired tenderness. (Note: turn often to prevent peppers and onions from sticking to pan.)
- Meanwhile, place steaks on a cutting board and carefully slice into very thin slices. (I found it easier to cut the steaks on an angle.) In a small bowl, toss the slices of steak with 2 Tbsp olive oil and salt and pepper (to taste).
- Once peppers and onions are close to desired tenderness, place steak slices in a hot cast iron or fry pan and cook until done. (Depending on the thickness of your slices, the sliced steak should cook in just a few minutes.)
- Once steak is almost done, divide into 2 portions in the pan. Place a piece of Provolone cheese on top of each portion and continue cooking until cheese is melted throughout steak.
- Using a spatula, place steak and cheese onto a hoagie bun and top with peppers and onions. Serve hot.
But wait…there’s more! If you happen to live near one of the cities below, then check out the official Walmart Steak-Over Challenge presented by Kingsford® Charcoal, Dr. Pepper® and A.1.® steak sauce. Local firefighters from eight different cities will compete to determine who has the best steak-grilling chops in town.
Walmart shoppers in each city will get a front row seat to the event, which will take place in the parking lot of their local Walmart store. Shoppers who attend will have the chance to join in the festivities, taste test Walmart USDA Choice Premium steaks, sample Dr. Pepper and A.1. steak sauce for free, and cast their vote for best steak.
The firefighter finalist from each city will compete on behalf of their station for a $20,000 grand prize in Los Angeles, the week of May 20.
2013 competitions include:
- Jacksonville, Florida: March 23
- San Antonio, Texas: March 30
- Tampa, Florida: April 6
- Charlotte, North Carolina: April 13
- Atlanta, Georgia: April 20
- Kansas City, Missouri: April 27
- Houston, Texas: May 4
- Indianapolis, Indiana: May 11
- Los Angeles, California: Week of May 20
Are you ready to experience Walmart’s Steak-Over for yourself? Find out why you should choose your steaks at Walmart here. We shared our winning grilling tip – now tell us yours!
Disclosure: Compensation was provided by Walmart. However, the opinions expressed herein are entirely those of the author.

















Recent Comments